|
| |
PHARMACOTHERAPY FOR ADHD IN ADULTS
by John J. Ratey M.D., Edward M. Hallowell, M.D. and Catherine L. Leveroni,
B.A.
ADHD in adults is very responsive to pharmacotherapy; however,
treatment strategies for the disorder have not been as well established as
they have for children. In this paper we will discuss our clinical
experience in treating adults with ADHD, in hopes that others will benefit
from the years of trial and error.
The challenge to treating the ADHD adult is finding the drug or
combination of drugs that work for the individual. Zametkin et al. (1990)
found evidence of hypometabolism of the brains of ADHD adults as compared
with matched controls, and the constellation of symptoms found in the
individual with ADHD, particularly the distractibility and motor
hyperactivity, may be explained by these differences. A useful metaphor
for ADHD that we have adopted, supported in part by Zametkin's findings,
may be the problem of underactivity in the frontal lobes.
The frontal lobes are thought to be mainly inhibitory and integrative
in function, thus hypoactivity may translate phenomenologicaily into
problems with inhibition and control in ADHD patients-problems with
stopping the flow of attention, thoughts, emotions, movements, ideas. The
precise pathophysiology of ADHD, however, has yet to be determined, and
the inconsistent results of research and clinical drug trials indicate
that ADHD is not of homogeneous neurochemical or anatomical origin. It is
thus difficult to predict to which drug an individual will best respond.
The clinician and the patient should try several medications at carefully
adjusted doses until the individual's optimal response is found and side
effects are minimized. There's no cookbook recipe and no cure for ADHD,
however the positive effect of the right drug or the right combination of
medications is often life changing for the patient and for those affected
by the patient.
ANTIDEPRESSANTS
Research and clinical experience have shown that the antidepressants
Norpramin (desipramine) and Tofranil (imipranine) effectively increase
attentiveness and reduce distractibility in children and adults. Tricyclic
antidepressants exert their effect by acting upon norepinephrine and
dopamine, the two major neurotransmitters in the attention system. They
block the re-uptake of norepinephrine and dopamine into the presynaptic
neuron and indirectly modify the rate of release, thus increase the
activity of these two chemicals in the brain (McCracken, 1991).
In our clinical experience, 40% or more of ADHD adults respond to
between 5 mg/day and 40 mg/day of Norpramin. This dose range is
considerably lower than that reported in current research reports (Biederman
et al, 1985; Biederman, 1988). We see the return to the use of low doses
as a significant contribution to the practice of pharmacotherapy for ADHD
because we have found the most dramatic responses at low dose levels.
Furthermore, most of our patients report that the positive effect
experienced at a very low dose range is often lost as the dose is
increased. In the mid 1960's, Rapoport reported that the majority of
children with "behavior problems" he studied showed marked
improvement on 10 mg/day of Tofranil; in fact, a number responded most
dramatically to 5 mg/day, and were maintained at that dose without a
waning of response (Rapoport, 1965).
As experience with antidepressants accumulated, researchers and
clinicians became aware that large doses and therapeutic blood levels of
antidepressants were useful in treating refractory depression. This
conflicted, buried, and colored the early experience of using lower doses
for anxiety, panic and especially for ADHD. The rapid time frame for drug
effect in ADHD patients, however, suggests that tricyclics have a
different mechanism of action in ADHD than they do in depression. It makes
sense, then, that the therapeutic dose range for ADHD would be different.
In clinical practice the superior efficacy of low doses has been
documented throughout the years (Heussy, 1983, 1989, 1992; Bellak et al.,
1987). In fact, Heussy has contended that there is a 90% chance
individuals with ADHD will have a positive response to a low dose of
tricyclics, which is between 1/10 to 1/3 of the dose used for depression.
We typically start people on 10 mg/day for a week to 10 days to see if
there is any improvement in the individual's ability to sustain attention
and regulate mood, and then proceed to raise the dose to 20 or 30 mg/day
if there is little or no response. We have found that Norpramin not only
increases the ability to direct and maintain attention, but also can have
a calming effect on the individual. It can decrease impulsive behavior,
stop temper tantrums, regulate frequent mood shifts and increase reading
and learning abilities. Norpramin also effectively treats the "mini
panic state" to which so many individuals with ADHD are prone. This
state begins as a startle response when the individual is flooded with
stimulation, and develops into a full blown feeling of panic which
predisposes the individual towards impulsive action, defense rumination or
the repetition of trauma experiences. This is a particularly salient
problem for ADHD adults, whose tolerance for stimulation is lowered
because they have spent most of their lives trying to sustain focus over
an inner state of chaos and turbulence.
The effect of the antidepressant in treating ADHD symptoms, especially
the mood instability, mini panic episodes, fuzziness of the environment,
and the chronic state of disorganization can be sometimes altered with the
first dose of medication. In others the effect can be subtle and gradual.
These changes can be very exciting for people who have struggled with
these symptoms for their entire life. Often patients will call the
clinician proclaiming Norpramin to be a "miracle drug." Both the
patient and physician should be skeptical of this effect until they see
positive markers of change in the patients life such as higher tests
scores and assignments completed in class for adolescents and young
adults; projects done on time, punctuality in meetings, checkbooks
balanced, tantrums a distant memory, and loved ones finding a new
attentive, intimate being for adults. The use of low doses also protects
against the adverse effects on memory and learning that is seen at higher
doses.
Another antidepressant that is currently popular among clinicians
treating adult ADHD is Wellbutrin (buproprion), which is a potent dopamine
re-uptake inhibitor. Research reports have attested to the moderate
efficacy of this agent (Wender and Reimhen; 1940).
STIMULANTS
If response to antidepressants is not apparent or begins to wane
within 4-6 weeks, we would try psychostimulants such as Ritalin
(methylphenidate), Dexedrine (amphetamine), and Cylert (pemoline). The
calming effect of these agents in hyperactive children is paradoxical, but
advances in the understanding of how these drugs work have provided
insight into their clinical effect. These drugs potently increase the
concentration and activity of both dopamine and norepinephrine, and thus
possibly enhance activity and inhibition in the brain. According to some
reports, Ritalin and Dexedrine increase attentiveness, reduce
distractibility, enhance concentration, and decrease motor restlessness
and hyperactivity in roughly 70% of adults with ADD (Barkley, 1977).
We would typically begin by starting Ritalin at 5 mg twice daily, then
increase the dose upward, with most people ending at a dose between 30-40
mg/day. Many people find adequate calming and attention enhancing effects
at lower doses (10-30 mg/day). This response can be immediate, and often
dramatic. If the individual does not respond to Ritalin we switch to
Dexedrine. It is crucial to note that Ritalin and Dexedrine, while widely
regarded as very similar drugs, are not. They have a different
pharmacological profile, a different mechanism of action at the cellular
level, and a not so subtly different effect on patients. The two drugs act
upon separate neurotransmitter storage pools. For instance, Ritalin is a
more potent re-uptake blocker of dopamine, while Dexedrine may exert some
of its effect through feedback inhibition (Zametkin et al, 1985). We have
found that when Dexedrine is successfully tried on people who have had an
unsatisfactory trial of Ritalin, they report that the Dexedrine is a
"softer drug." Some patients feel Dexedrine is enormously
beneficial in alerting their brain to activity without causing them to
feel somatically driven, as compared to Ritalin which sometimes makes
patients feel like their body is in "overdrive." One patient
described Dexedrine as a "caffeine-less" Ritalin. Most
clinicians, however, use Dexedrine as the second or third choice stimulant
because of its reputation in the drug abusing community.
Side effects with the psychostimulants on the whole are low as compared
to other psychoactive agents that psychiatrists and neurologists use.
Major complaints involve appetite suppression, insomnia or multiple
varieties of sleep disturbance such as waking up in middle of the night
and interference with dreams. Ten percent of patients on Ritalin complain
of headaches, and the clinician must watch blood pressure and pulse when
either psychostimulant is used. A more important issue in prescribing
psychostimulants is the difficulty in achieving a therapeutic dose of
medication. Sometimes a patient needs very little medication, for instance
we have those in our practice who find that as little as 1/4 mg Ritalin or
Dexedrine a few times a day provides them with the necessary enhancement
of focusing ability. Others need much higher doses to sustain an effect,
and require levels well beyond the recommended upper limit of 60 mg/day of
Ritalin.
Gittleman-Klein has stated that the most commonly made error in the
treatment of ADHD is inadequate dosing (Gittleman-Klein, 1987). This is
most likely due to habit, worry about addiction, or a cognitive commitment
to a cookbook dogma that deflates the role of the patient's report as the
primary measure of drug response. For these individuals there is the
problem of maintaining an adequate dose of medication. The drug is
available in 5 mg tablets, and adults may need 20 mg per dose to get a
calming, focusing effect, and this lasts only 3-4 hours. For many people
there is a limit to the number of pills that one can take or will remember
to take. We sometimes use a slow release stimulant to counter this problem
particularly in individuals who are likely to forget to take a 2nd or 3rd
dose of medication; however, it has been our observation that Cylert
generally does not induce as dramatic results as Ritalin or Dexedrine.
Dexedrine slow release, which is available in 10 mg spansules, seems to be
more effective than slow release Ritalin. It would be wonderful to have a
long acting stimulant, but currently there is not a clinically efficacious
one available.
Scientists have discovered a way to chemically purify Ritalin into a
more effective drug with fewer side effects; however, the development of
this specifically targeted drug is pending funding (Jaffe, 1992). Another
frequently encountered problem in prescribing psychostimulants is
negotiating with pharmacists. There is a persistent dark cloud hanging
over the use of stimulants because of their tarnished history as drugs of
abuse. Even in the most enlightened states it is difficult to prescribe
psychostimulants for adults due to the prevailing myths that ADHD is 1)
not a disorder but merely moral corruptness and 2) something that
disappears in adolescence. It is thus often thought that adults who are
taking prescription psychostimulants are simply looking for their next
high. In many cases, the physician must call the pharmacy before the drug
will be dispensed.
This brings up the issue frequently faced by mental health
professionals, parents, and concerned others of whether it is wise to use
stimulant medication in individuals with a history of drug or alcohol
abuse. This is fraught with anxiety on everyone's part; however it has
been our experience that an adult with history of drug and/or alcohol
abuse who has been diagnosed with ADHD and is committed to changing
his/her life will not use the medication in an illegal or abusive fashion.
This obviously presupposes a very strong therapeutic relationship with the
prescribed as well as with other involved mental health professionals.
Furthermore, Huessey has written that no cases of psychostimulant abuse in
ADHD adolescents have been reported because the drugs are not used to
"tune out" of the environment as are most recreational drugs,
but to "tune in" (Huessey, 1985).
OTHER AGENTS
It has been suggested that a number of other agents, such as
fenfluramine, L-dopa, and amantadine, may be used to treat ADHD. These are
possibly useful drugs where others fail, but neither research (Zametkin
and Rapoport, 1987) nor clinical experience has shown these agents to be
as effective as the psychostimulants and tricyclic antidepressants. These
drugs should be tried as a last resort in the rare case of a treatment
failure to the latter agents.
ADJUNCTS
While treatment with stimulants and tricyclics are extremely effective
in enhancing concentration and attention, they often cannot sufficiently
ameliorate the concomitant impulsivity, explosiveness, and irritability
experienced by many ADHD adults. There are many adjunct medications that
can be added to the treatment regimen to help with these symptoms.
Beta-blockers can be used to decrease anxiety and tension. They also
reduce hyper-responsiveness to stimulation, and the agitation that
predisposes many ADHD adults to impulsive behavior and tantrums. Corgard (nadolol)
is preferable to Inderal (propranol) because it can be taken once a day
and it mainly has a peripheral mechanism of action, therefore reduces the
chronic somatic tension, hyperarousal, and impulsivity without interfering
with the effects of other medications. Lithium, Depakote (valproate), and
Tegretol (carbamazepine) can also be very useful adjuncts in violent and
difficult to manage individuals, especially in those whose behavior is
secondary to extreme fluctuations of mood.
Another drug that is often useful as an adjunctive treatment for ADHD
is Clonidine, an agent which alters alpha-adrenergic functioning (Hunt,
1987). Clonidine is especially helpful in increasing calmness and
frustration tolerance, particularly in a patient who cannot take
beta-blockers because of a past history of asthma. Clonidine may also
enhance the efficacy of a stimulant at the receptor level (Hunt, 1985),
thus enabling the clinician to lower the stimulant dose. Clonidine's use
in adults, however, can be complicated because of its tendency to induce
somnolence.
An extremely common concurrent complaint in ADHD adults is that of
depression and irritability, particularly in ADHD women who suffer from
PMS. It seems no matter how effective the stimulants or tricyclics are in
increasing the ability to focus, symptoms in these individuals fluctuate
with the monthly variations in mood. These symptoms respond very well to
the serotonergic agents BuSpar (buspirone) and Prozac (fluoxetine). The
improvement gained with the addition of these drugs to the treatment
regimen of individuals prone to irritability and depression is often
dramatic. We typically start patients on standard doses, 10 mg/T.I.D., of
Buspar or 20 mg q AM of Prozac for an entire month until symptoms have
been obliterated, then switch to an attempt to use medication only 2 weeks
of the month. Prozac can also reduce the obsessive/compulsive symptoms
some patients develop in response to their ADHD. We have not found
traditional doses of Anafranil (clomipramine) to be useful in adults with
ADHD.
It is important to note that none of the drugs used as adjuncts induce
cognitive impairment. This is crucial because as the ability to remember,
learn, organize, and relate all tend to be impaired in ADHD adults, the
enhancement of these functions is an important aspect of treatment.
THE MYTH THAT THE DOCTOR KNOWS ALL
In assessing an individual's response to a particular medication or
dose, the best advice we have is to listen carefully to the patient
because their feelings are more accurate gages of drug efficacy than are
so-called objective scales or doctor's impressions. This can be
complicated because many ADHD adults are poor observers of their own
activity, and have difficulty with retrospective assessments of their
behavior or mood state. It is also helpful to enlist the help of other
observers such as spouses, friends, and coworkers, as these people are
often the most sensitive to changes in ADHD adults once treatment has
begun.
The treating clinician should also be aware that there are a few
patients among ADHD adults, perhaps 1 in 10, who have extremely sensitive
brains. There are many possible causes of this hypersensitivity, such as a
history of brain injury, premature delivery or birth trauma. It is
important that this reaction not be interpreted as resistance, a negative
therapeutic reaction, or passive-aggression. We have seen a number of
individuals for whom even 10 mg of antidepressant or 5 mg of
methylphenidate is far too much. Unfortunately for some of these patients
there is not a dose low enough: even if they chop off tiny pieces of
medication, they still have too many side effects. In these cases, both
the clinician and patient are left in a quandary without medication as a
treatment option. |
adult shopping, amateur photographic models, hardcore anal sex, sexy asian teen, huge ass, ass parade flower, bbw singles, free amature bdsm video, voyeur beach video, free beastiality movie trailers, sexy bikini gros seins, bisexual foot fetish, , blonde lesbians kissing, public blowjobs sluts, self bondage stories, hilary duff's boobs, retro vintage cowboy boots, brazil sol hardcore mike in brazil, sleazy brunette, tight butt, sex web cam, cartoon network porn, nudity celeb pics, free nude male celeb pictures, cheerleaders masturbating, sex chicks, naked chicks with guns, closeup penis, huge cock blowjobs, socal coed sex, internal creampie animal, facial cumshots jpg, dad incest, dating atlanta black escorts, pam anderson sucking dick, strap-on dildo, sex dirty, lesbian domination vids, adult dvd download, ebony cum shot, nude contortionists erotica, ethnic fucking, animal face paint, close up facial, final fantasy hentai doujinshi, fat facials, free gay feet clips, female masterbation techniques, free foot fetish videos, femdom strapon ffm, cunt fisting, flexible led strips, free anal videos, bitch fuck, gang fighting, bobby manila's black attack gangbang, little gay boys, gothic girl porn, dad girl, gnant group sex, free hairy black teens, sandra handjob, ebony hardcore fucking, anime shemales, free horny housewife pic, jab incest, indians nude, latin nude, girl legs, lesbian 101, topless lingerie, live cam feed, home made penis masturbation machine, ohio greenville maid rite, french maid spankings, homemade masturbation, free mature porn thumbnails, mature fucking teen, gay men wrestling, muscle gay midgets, milf movie, us military hand to hand combat video, , smash mouth mp3, blowjob movies, photo dynamic therapy toe nail fungus, brooke burke naked, freehand nail art designs, morgan webb nude, lesbians nurses, naked nylons, office anal, oral boys, fingering a woman orgasm, free pictures of outdoor masturbation, cheap flight paris to london, cum party sluts, peep toe pumps, lil bo peep sexy halloweeen costumes, free porn for women, free pornstar thumbs, top 50 busty pornstars, public bj mpegs, free bald pussy galleries, pictures duke lacrosse rape case, reality porn movie clips, redhead 69, scat man john, schoolgirl tits, porn boss fucking secretary, free sex teen galleries, shaved pussys, shemale movie, shower sex pics, silicone lips fuck, , ex wife slut, interacial smoking erotica, birthday spanking story, schoolgirls in stockings sading, hung gay studs, pamela suck, first cum swallow, bronco 11 engien swap, tanned blowjob, cover up tattoos, teen love quotes, teens wearing thongs to young, slit throat, tiny innocent, tits with milk, toon cunt, oregon toy poodle, sapphire tranny, body kits, cum twink, cub scout uniform, upskirt club, pubescent vagina, video sexe, free voyeur photos 23, angel wife lovers, xxx passwords, young latina models, 00 season youth baseball tournament, zoo bestiality search, adult frend finder, amateur hand job, anal shots, nude asian chicks, free ass pics, ripped asshole, bbw chat, bdsm puppy play, beach teens asian, beastiality rar, bikini wrestling females, bisexual men and wife photos, slutty bitches, busty blonde lesbians, office blowjob, , , discount womens cowboy boots, braless brazil, petite brunette nude, butt girl, spy cam sex, big cartoon boobs, celeb uncensored, celebreties in linerie, cheerleader spanking, football chicks, chubby porn movies, pussy pic closeup, cock brutality, coeds 69, hot dowloadable creampie videos, massive cumshot, daughter and dad porn, carbon dating material, black boy dick, women dildo, angels with dirty faces, , upcoming dvd release dates, xxx ebony, erotica noir, ethnic shemale mpegs, extreme face fucking, huge facial cumshots, fantasy football rankings free, fat gay cocks, big fat tits, nude female athletes, underwater fetish, anal ffm cum, rimming, race car flexible body, free gay chat, titty fuck free, nuestra familia prison gang, rape gangbang, gay voyeur, gothic girl naked, dads whore, gay social groups florida, hairy dildo, handjob pics, hardcore junky, extreme hentai, xxx housewives videos, son mom incest, indian nudes, latin female models, black girls open legs, lesbian shower sex, naked women in lingerie, dorm cams live, washing machine repair, transvestite sissy maids, male teen, masturbation toys, very mature ladies, hot tub melons, nude old men, men fucking boys, what does milf stand for, military pay chart 2006, mom and dad sex, black midget dick, tit fucking movies, in-grown toe nail, getting naked, teen nipples, nude girls in shower, nurses hardcore, double nylon panties, office tit fuck, best oral sex, females multiple orgasm, caught girls pissing outdoor, paris hotels near the louvre museum, las vegas bachelor parties, deluxe little bo peep costume, gay anal double penetration, free gay porn galleries, straight male pornstars, , public lesbian sex, pussy ejaculation, rape survivors pamphlets, free hard core porn reality sites, sexy redhead teens 01, free japanese scat, naked schoolgirl pussy, arts and craft style, sex education, shaved tgp, active shemale escorts, boys in the shower, silicone breast implant life span, skinny cunt, club sluts, women smoking naked, otk spanking adult, , hot studs masturbating, suck black cock, gag swallow, rule yankee swap, tanned orgasm, blowjob wife sex swap, petite teen fuck, hot thongs, ap sinus problems sore throat, tiny tease, voluptuous tits, free naked toons, adult sex toy store, tranny galleries, hardcore toon lesbians, free gay twink gallery posts, pros and cons about school uniforms, upskirt amateur, growth inside vagina, twink cum swallow, tennis voyeur, wife nude, free xxx long movies, gay xxx cum shot, idaho youth sex offender programs, fucking zoo,
|